[George Dangerfield] read The Strange Death of Liberal England PDF


  • Paperback
  • 364
  • The Strange Death of Liberal England
  • George Dangerfield
  • English
  • 12 December 2017
  • 9780804729307

George Dangerfield ☆ 5 Summary

The Strange Death of Liberal England Summary ½ 5 Is one of the most important books of the English past a prime example that history can be abiding literature As a portrait of England enmeshed in the turbulence of new movements which often led to violence against the pieties of Liberal England until it was overwhelmed by the greatest violence of all World War I this extraordinary book has continued to exert a powerful influence on the way historians have observed early twentieth century England. This book moved between a three and a four I think his writerly ways did not always make for clarity of content I really liked his chapter on the suffragists and I learned a lot from his discussion of the worker s movements especially the miners His political section with its discussion of unionism was the weakest at least for me I had a hard time following it and while some of it was due to my own lack of knowledge some was definitely a kind of writerly fog

Summary ´ PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ☆ George DangerfieldThe Strange Death of Liberal England

The Strange Death of Liberal England Summary ½ 5 At the beginning of the twentieth century England's empire spanned the globe its economy was strong and its political system seemed immune to the ills that inflicted so many other countries After a resounding electoral triumph in 1906 the Liberals formed the government of the most powerful nation on earth yet within a few years the House of Lords lost its absolute veto over legislation the Home Rule crisis brought Ireland to the brink of civil war. When was the last time you laughed out loud while reading a history book Yep that s what I thought Well this book did it for me The topic of course is not funny George Dangerfield explains how early England had a Cerberus of its own the Tory Party the Women s Suffrage movement and the Worker s rebellion which caused the downfall of the Liberal Partyoh with some help from the party itself I must say that the Tory Party digging in to refuse to work with the Liberal Party during this era seemed somewhat contemporary history does repeat itselfNo what s funny is Dangerfield s dry sarcasm even though he ultimately lived in the US he was born and schooled in England and the tone is very Englishas well as flowery and poetic as is the language of many of the classic historians It s a gorgeous book to read and believe it or not gripping there are scenes that are written with an immediacy that made me feel as if I were thereIt doesn t hurt of course that I love the pre World War I period of English history and Dangerfield showed me how much I didn t know about it his writing this history at the time he did this history was published in 1935 just about twenty years after the events he describes also offers a perspective that we don t often experience The book ends with the death of Rupert Brooke in 1915 and a lofty and beautiful paragraph with his death one sees the extinction of Liberal England Standing beside that moonlit grave one looks back All the violence of the pre war world has vanished and in its place there glow year into backward year the diminishing vistas of that other England the England where the Grantchester church clock stood at ten to three where there was Beauty and Certainty and uiet and where nothing was real Today we know it for what it was but there are moments very human moments when we could almost find it in our hearts to envy those who saw it and who never lived to see the new world The italics are mine as dated as this view is this is what I think of when I think of England and English historythe beauty and uiet of an unchanging England Totally wrong of course but it never ceases to make me smile

review The Strange Death of Liberal England

The Strange Death of Liberal England Summary ½ 5 And led to an army mutiny the campaign for woman's suffrage created widespread civil disorder and discredited the legal and penal systems and an unprecedented wave of strikes swept the landThis is a classic account first published in 1935 of the dramatic upheaval and political change that overwhelmed England in the period 1910 1914 Few books of history retain their relevance and vitality after than sixty years The Strange Death of Liberal England. This is rich in ideas abstractions and issues unacknowledged for years the book dates from 1937 For that alone it is fascinating But there are glaring flaws Its treatment of the suffragettes is downright venal Most praise its prose style but I found it repetitive and distracting the satire and meanness hid clarity What for example does this meanTo reduce the Liberal Party to a definition would be like attempting to reduce the glandular contours of a circus Fat Lady by simply talking her thinFor the sudden loss of prosperity of England s lower classes he blames the new financier the new plutocrat with little of the responsibility which once had sanctioned the power of England s landed classes In truth the issue was the gold standard which since the discovery of South African gold subjected the Pound to fantastic price inflationThe writing does improve in the second half egThe instinct of the British worker was very active in 1910 It warned him that he was underpaid that Parliament left to itself would keep him underpaid it told him that good behavior had ceased to have any meaning it asserted that he must unite at any costWhen political democracy itself is being uestioned blindly perhaps and instinctively and when so anomalous figure as David Lloyd George thrusts himself into the debate a simple conundrum will very likely be asked When is a friend of the people not a friend of the people And the answer would appear to be when he is a Cabinet MinisterBut ultimately the book fails to prove its case what caused the downfall of liberal England The author only glancingly addresses the eclipse of the Liberal party by Labour Instead he provides disconnected narratives about the House of Lords veto labor strikes the age old Irish uestion and most oddly in the Epilogue the life of poet Rupert Brooke The closest thing to explanation I understood was that the workers ran away with the Trade Unions and perhaps the violent suffragettes with the peaceful distaff side Or perhaps the author means to lay blame paraphrasing Home Secretary McKenna s autobiography onthe sad effects on society of the invasion of industrial millionaires and Rand magnates and Jews and American heiresses who found their way into the most sacred enclosures of Cowes Ascot and Convent GardenSo English liberalism died of democracy RIPPS It didn t escape me that the author means to say that the aristocracy ceased to represent the people But anyone who s read Jeeves knew that